Restoring the Privileges or Immunities Clause
Why the 14th Amendment matters in the fight for a free society
Damon W. Root | February 23, 2009
Last week the Institute for Justice (I.J.), a public interest law firm dedicated to protecting economic and political liberty, filed a federal lawsuit on behalf of Boston entrepreneur Erroll Tyler, whose attempts to start an amphibious sightseeing business have been repeatedly thwarted by city officials who refuse to grant him a license. Under state law, the Boston police commissioner has the authority to regulate all sightseeing vehicles that either originate in the city or stop there to pick up passengers. Yet as the lawsuit notes, Tyler's operation will be based out of nearby Cambridge and his vehicles will make no stops within Boston. They will simply travel the streets like any other car, truck, or bus, making their way to Boston Harbor, where they will fall under federal jurisdiction. For its part, the city claims that a massive public works project that has had no impact on traffic for the last three years requires a "moratorium" on new sightseeing licenses.
This is a classic case of unnecessary and arbitrary regulations that violate fundamental economic rights. It's also significant because I.J. has brought suit under the Privileges or Immunities Clause of the 14th Amendment, which reads, "No state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States." (The suit cites the amendment's Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses as well.) The Privileges or Immunities Clause, which was designed to protect substantive individual rights from state abuse, has been essentially dead since the Supreme Court's 1873 decision in The Slaughterhouse Cases, which held that it guarantees only a narrow set of national rights, such as the freedom to travel between states.
Given that I.J. has unsuccessfully raised the issue before, why try to resurrect the clause now? The answer is District of Columbia v. Heller, the Court's landmark 2008 decision holding that the Second Amendment secures an individual right to keep and bear arms and that D.C.'s gun laws violated that right. One big question Heller did not answer is whether the Second Amendment applies only to the federal government (which oversees Washington, D.C.) or to state and local governments as well. That's where the 14th Amendment comes in. Through a series of decisions, the Court has gradually "incorporated" most of the Bill of Rights, making its guarantees applicable to the states via the 14th Amendment's Due Process Clause. When the question of Second Amendment incorporation inevitably reaches the Supreme Court, the Privileges or Immunities Clause also is likely to receive some long overdue attention. Last month, I.J. filed a friend of the court brief (PDF) in the case of McDonald v. Chicago, which challenges Chicago's draconian gun control laws, providing detailed historical evidence that the Privileges or Immunities Clause "protects substantive rights from incursion by state and local governments, and [that] the right of citizens to keep and bear arms for self-defense is among the most important of those rights."
the rest of the article can be found here.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Obama Watch
- "The Making of George W. Obama." Foreign Policy Magizine
- Obama Bush Continuity: Reason TV: Barrack W. Bush
- Obama Top Economic Advisors Took Bribes from JP Morgan, Goldman Sachs, Others
- WSJ: Obama Using TARP to Control Banks
- WSJ to Obama: How Not to Fight Discrimination
- Reuters: Businesses Move to Switzerland to Avoid Obama
- Economist Give Obama and Team Failing Grade So Far
- Newsweek, Howard Fineman Critiques Obama: "He'd have made a fine judge. But we don't need a judge."
- Liberal Economist Paul Krugman Criticises Pres. Obama's Economics
- Wall Street Journal: Is Our Troubled Economy a Responce to Obama's Policies?
- Jim Cramer: Is this Friend of Democrats on Obama's Enemies List? His Responce.
- Reuters: Obama Budget Sends $11,000 Bill to Every American
- Wall Street Journal: Obama's Mortgage Plan: Dukes of Moral Hazzard
- Obama Rhetoric is a Real Problem - Wall Street Journal
- CATO Calls Out Obama Admin's Lie About Economists
- Congressional Budget Office Says Obama Stimulus Will Hurt Economy in Long Term
- Peter Schiff (you know, the guy who predicted the current crisis) Say Obama Stimulus Will be a Disaster
- Obama "Stimulus" Bill May Have Serious Problems
Past Articles: March 24 - Aprile 16
- WSJ: The Greatness of Capitalism Can Save Us: Lessons from the Recovery of 2001
- Democrats: Merit-Based Pay? Fugetaboutit !
- Deregulation? Bush was the Biggest Regulator in Decades
- The Best Way to Rob a Bank is to Own One
- Cost for Bailout Jumps...Again.
- Watchdogs: Treasury Still Wont Release Details of Bailouts
- How NOT to Fight Discrimination - Obama Admin Goes After Wal-Mart
- "A Moderate Manifesto" David Brooks Feels Betrayed By Obama - NYTIMES
- George Will - The Toxic Assets We Elected
- The REAL AIG Disgrace - WSJ
Past Articles of the Day - Feb 9 - March 24 2008
- Wells Fargo Chief Critiques Bailout, Calls Plan "Asinine"
- Government Forces Doctor to Raise Fees
- NY Times: "Stimulus Report" Further Evidence that Central Planning Does Not Work
- Bailout Woes Continue With Citi
- WSJ: How California Became France. (one of the best articles I have read)
- Investing Legend Jim Rogers Speaks on the Economy
- The Popular Uprising Against Central Banking
- Tax Payer Risk 9.7 Trillion on Crisis
- Pushing Banks to Loan Could Backfire - WSJ
- Fed Still Refuses to Disclose Recipients of 2 Trillion Dollars
- Government Watchdog Agencies Chide Treasury On Bailout Handling - WSJ
- China Lectures Paulson on Economic Policy - US No Longer Holds Moral High Ground
- Sen. Jim Demint: "Republicans Must Fight for Freedom to Regain America's Trust"
- The Other Auto Industry
- Is Uncle Sam's Credit Line Running Out?
- Obama's Clinton Problem: Deregulation Led to the Prosperity of the 90's; Just Ask Bill Clinton
Past Articles of the Day
- Why Republicans Need to Get Back to their Roots
- Gun Control and Crime
- Myth: Ethanol is Great.
- Silly Senator, Corn is for Food! Why Ethanol is not What It's Cracked Up to Be.
- Freedom to Choose Flat Tax
- What Happened to Detriot
- Great Article on Ivy League Schools by William Deresiewicz
- America is the World's Highest Drug User
- Petro-politics: As Oil Prices Rise, Human Rights Go Down. by Thomas Friedman, Foreign Policy Magazine
- Finally! Democrats Vote to "Privatize" a Wastful Goverment Program!!!
- Unlike Others, U.S. Defends Freedom to Offend in Speech - NYTimes
- Wall Street Journal: "Our Collectivist Candidates" by David Boaz
- We Knew About the "Housing Crisis" Well Before it Struck
- The Trillion Dollar War
- "Yes, the Market is Unfair" - Insightful Article on the Economics of the Stock Market
- Ron Paul's Libertarian Lesson for John McCain (U.S. News W.R.)
- Raw Milk - More Government Shutting Down Legitimate Business Under False Pretense
- 5 Myths About No Child Left Behind
- Making College More Expensive: The Unintended Consequences of Federal Tuition Aid
- What If Public Schools Were Abolished?
- Ten Days the Changed Capitalism
- Universal Health Care: '08 Presidential Race
- Florida Looks to Regulate Toilet Paper in Bathrooms
- "Unfettered Speech, Now" by Bradly Smith & Steve Simpson
- Litigating for Liberty
- 1 in 100 U.S. Adults Behind Bars, New Study Says
- Scalia the Civil Libertarian? by The New York Times
- Montana: They'll Cecede From the Union if Supreme Court Rules Wrong
- Of Horses Teeth and Liberty. by The Economist
- Americans Go to Mexico for Affordable Dental Care
- US Military May Not Be Ready for Attack
- How Cincinnati Turned It's Schools Around
- "Waving Goodbye to Hegemony" by Parag Khanna, NY Times
- "Social Entrepreneurs" - Better Than Government Activism
- The Education of Ben Bernake
- Bush's Stimulus Flop
- Stimulus Stupidity
- Inflation and the Tax Man
- Why Ignorance Is'nt Bliss. How Ignorance Threatens Democracy
- Newsweek: "Bothersome Intel on Iran"
- Liberal-tarians
- GOP Fusion Comes Unfused
- Financial Times: "An Ottoman warning for indebted America"
- "American Power. Still #1" by The Economist
- How to Fire and Incompetent Teacher
- Few senators read Iraq NIE report
- US Mercantilist Machismo, China Replaces Japan
- Ten Days the Changed Capitalism
No comments:
Post a Comment